Taxation of Customer-Funded Facility Expansions: A Technical Review of Thermal Circuits, Inc. v. Commissioner
The case of Thermal Circuits, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-29, centers on a manufacturing corporation that received substantial funds from a customer to expand its production capacity. Thermal Circuits, Inc. (Thermal), an accrual-method C corporation, manufactures foil heating components. In 2013, Nicoventures Trading Limited (NVT), a subsidiary of British American Tobacco, engaged Thermal to produce foil heating elements for electronic tobacco devices.
By 2016, NVT’s demand for the heaters significantly outpaced Thermal’s production capacity. NVT desired nearly 20 times the output without an increase in the $10 per-unit cost. To meet this volume at a fixed cost, Thermal needed a larger facility and more equipment. NVT ultimately agreed to fund an expansion of Thermal's leased manufacturing facility. In 2017, NVT paid $4.085 million toward the leasehold addition, followed by an additional $204,529 in 2018. Throughout construction, Thermal purchased necessary tools and machinery to populate the addition, billing NVT on a cost-plus basis. Once completed, Thermal paid the insurance and property taxes for the entire premises, including the new addition, and bore all attendant risks.
Read More