Corporate Distinctness and the Duty of Consistency: Analysis of Alioto v. Commissioner
In the recent decision of Alioto v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2025-125, the United States Tax Court addressed the consequences of a taxpayer failing to respect the separate existence of his closely held corporation. The Court ruled in favor of the Commissioner regarding deficiencies stemming from unreported wage income, constructive dividends, and capital gains, while simultaneously disallowing personal deductions for corporate business expenses. For tax professionals, this case serves as a stark reminder of the rigorous substantiation requirements for accountable plans and the application of the "duty of consistency" in preventing taxpayers from taking contrary positions to those of their controlled entities.
Read More