Seventh Circuit Clarifies Limits of Substantial Compliance Doctrine in ERISA Beneficiary Disputes: A Review of Packaging Corporation of America Thrift Plan v. Langdon
For tax professionals and estate planners advising clients on ERISA-governed retirement accounts, the designation of beneficiaries remains a critical area of compliance. The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit recently issued a decision in Packaging Corporation of America Thrift Plan v. Langdon, No. 25-1859 (7th Cir. Feb. 2, 2026), addressing the "substantial compliance" doctrine in the context of a post-divorce beneficiary change. This article details the procedural history, factual background, and the panel’s technical analysis regarding why an informal request to change a beneficiary failed to override the plan documents.
Read More