Taxation of Terminated Life Insurance Policies: An Analysis of Constructive Receipt and Investment Interest
Jonathan D. Sawyer v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, T.C. Memo. 2026-33 (April 16, 2026)
Jonathan Sawyer was the owner and chief executive officer of Henry N. Sawyer (HNS), a family printing business that operated from 1835 until its liquidation in 2010. In 1982, Mr. Sawyer purchased a $200,000 life insurance policy on himself through Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Co. (Northwestern) to provide for his wife in the event of his death. Due to occasional liquidity issues, Mr. Sawyer elected an automatic premium loan option, allowing Northwestern to secure premium payments by borrowing against the policy's cash surrender value to prevent the policy from lapsing.
Over the years, HNS experienced significant financial volatility, forcing Mr. Sawyer to repeatedly inject personal funds into the business to keep it afloat. In May 2009, Mr. Sawyer borrowed $80,000 from Northwestern, secured by the cash surrender value of the life insurance policy, and deposited the funds directly into HNS's business bank account. Despite these efforts, HNS liquidated in 2010. In 2015, the combined balances of the $80,000 policy loan and the accumulated premium loans eclipsed the policy's cash surrender value. Consequently, Northwestern automatically terminated the policy.
At the time of cancellation, the cash surrender value was $205,433.81, which Northwestern used in its entirety to satisfy the outstanding principal and interest of the loans. Mr. Sawyer's investment in the contract was $44,533.42, resulting in a taxable distribution of $160,900.39 reported on a Form 1099-R. Believing the Form 1099-R to be inaccurate, Mr. Sawyer did not file a 2015 federal income tax return, prompting the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to prepare a substitute for return (SFR) pursuant to I.R.C. § 6020(b) and issue a Notice of Deficiency.
Read More