Taxability of Social Security Repayments and the Claim of Right Doctrine: An Analysis of Smith v. Commissioner
In Smith v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-25, the Tax Court reviewed the 2022 individual income tax return of Michael Smith. During the 2022 tax year, Mr. Smith held jobs with two separate employers, receiving wages totaling $16,535, which he appropriately reported on his Form 1040. However, claiming a disabling injury, Mr. Smith applied for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits in April 2022.
In November 2022, the Social Security Administration (SSA) issued an award letter granting retroactive benefits, and Mr. Smith subsequently received SSDI payments spanning from March 2022 through March 2023. In total, the SSA paid Mr. Smith $26,802 in SSDI benefits during the 2022 tax year, which the agency reported to the IRS on Form SSA-1099. Mr. Smith did not report any of these benefits on his 2022 Form 1040.
In April 2023, the SSA ceased making disability payments after discovering Mr. Smith had been employed since April 2022. The SSA informed him that he "should have never been entitled to receive [a] Social Security disability benefit". Consequently, Mr. Smith was required to reimburse the SSA. He repaid $31,116 in May 2023 and fulfilled the remaining balance via monthly payments across 2023 and 2024. Upon examining his 2022 return, the IRS determined that 85% of the 2022 SSDI benefits ($22,782) should have been included in his gross income pursuant to IRC Sec. 86(a), resulting in a tax deficiency of $5,454.
Read More